Engineering consultancies operate in a highly competitive environment where bidding for the right projects can be the difference between sustainable growth and wasted resources. Many teams still use intuition and past experience to decide on bids – and this lack of project selection strategy can lead to inconsistent results.
A structured, data-driven approach can significantly improve decision-making, ensuring teams focus on projects that align with their strategic objectives, financial goals, and resource capabilities. This article explores how engineering consultancies can refine their bid/no-bid process using key data points, structured frameworks, and technology for winning bids.
The Traditional Challenge: Relying on Instinct
Historically, many energy and engineering consultancies have used a subjective approach to bid/no-bid decision-making. Often, there is no formal process. Many of us have attended meetings where someone makes a decision to bid after an undocumented chat. While experience and industry knowledge are crucial, poor engineering RFP evaluation methods often results in:
- Bidding on projects that are unlikely to be won
- Taking on projects with poor margins or high risks
- Wasting valuable time and resources on unqualified opportunities
With tighter profit margins and increasing competition, consultancies need a more analytical approach to ensure they pursue the right projects and increase their proposal success rate.
Key Data Points for Smarter Engineering Project Bid/No-Bid Decisions
A robust bid/no-bid framework should incorporate objective data to improve decision-making. Some essential data points include:
1. Financial Viability
- Estimated project revenue vs. cost
- Likely profit margins
- Payment terms and client financial stability
2. Resource Availability
- Current workload and capacity of key staff
- Availability of specialised expertise
- Alignment with ongoing projects to maximise efficiency
3. Competitive Landscape
- Number of competitors and their track record
- Your company’s unique differentiators
- Probability of winning based on past performance
4. Client History & Relationship
- Previous working relationship with the client
- Payment history and contract terms
- Long-term strategic value of the client
5. Project Risk & Complexity
- Technical challenges and feasibility
- Regulatory and compliance considerations
- Risk mitigation strategies required
Using this structured evaluation, engineering consultancies can move beyond guesswork and make more calculated decisions.
Building a Structured Framework for Bid/No-Bid Decisions
To formalise the process, teams should establish a structured decision-making framework that includes:
1. A Scoring System
Assign numerical values to key factors like financial viability, competition, and risk. This creates a standardised assessment where projects must meet a minimum score to proceed.
2. A Go/No-Go Checklist
A structured checklist can include:
- Is the project within our core expertise?
- Do we have the required resources?
- Does it align with our strategic goals?
- Is the expected margin within our target range?
- Are the risks manageable?
3. Stakeholder Input & Decision Approval
Key team members, including project managers, finance, and legal teams, should provide input before a final decision is made.
Technology’s Role in Bid Selection
Traditional bid/no-bid processes often rely on gut instinct, ad hoc discussions, or scattered spreadsheets. However, modern technology, such as Proteus’ Opportunity Feature, allows consultancies to take a structured, data-driven approach to bid assessment.
1. Centralised Opportunity Management
Proteus provides a single platform where all potential opportunities are logged, ensuring key stakeholders have access to the same information. This eliminates fragmented decision-making and enables a more transparent, structured review process.
2. Objective Bid Scoring & Analytics
Proteus allows engineering consultancies to score opportunities based on pre-defined criteria, such as strategic fit, risk level, financial viability, and probability of winning. By applying weighted scoring models, teams can compare multiple opportunities side by side and focus on those with the highest strategic value.
3. Auditable Decision-Making Process
One of the biggest challenges in bid/no-bid decisions is the lack of documentation and post-decision review. Proteus creates a fully auditable trail of bid discussions, approvals, and justifications. This allows leadership to revisit past decisions, analyse trends, and refine bid strategies over time.
4. Workflow Automation & Approvals
Proteus automates the approval process by allowing stakeholders to review, comment on, and approve bids within the platform. Notifications ensure that decisions are made promptly, preventing delays in responding to high-value opportunities.
5. Integration with Project Delivery
Successful bid decisions should feed seamlessly into project execution. Proteus ensures that once a project is won, all relevant data, including financial projections, are automatically transferred into project management workflows. Proteus uses the information from the Opportunity stage to create WBS, schedules, organograms, and budgeting tables. This content is then optimised to ensure the content is ideal for engineering consultancy proposals. This reduces manual handovers and improves efficiency.
Case Study: Data-Driven Decision-Making in Action
A mid-sized engineering consultancy specialising in infrastructure projects previously struggled with bid efficiency, often chasing low-margin projects. By implementing a structured bid/no-bid framework and using technology to track bid performance, they achieved:
- A 25% reduction in wasted bid resources
- A 15% increase in win rate
- Improved profitability by focusing on high-value opportunities
This example highlights how structured decision-making can enhance business outcomes.
Looking Forward: The Future of Bid Efficiency
As the engineering sector continues to evolve, consultancies that adopt a data-driven, strategic approach to bidding will gain a competitive edge. Companies that integrate technology into their bid/no-bid decision-making process will be better positioned to:
- Improve win rates
- Reduce wasted effort on low-value bids
- Align projects with long-term strategic growth
By transitioning from instinct-based decisions to data-backed strategies, engineering consultancies can optimise resource allocation, increase profitability, and secure a stronger position in the market.
Conclusion
The bid/no-bid decision is one of the most critical aspects of business development in engineering consultancies. Relying on gut instinct alone is no longer sustainable in an increasingly competitive landscape. By leveraging key data points, implementing a structured decision-making framework, and utilising technology, businesses can make smarter, more profitable bidding decisions.
For engineering consultancies looking to improve their bid processes, now is the time to embrace a more analytical and systematic approach.
About Proteus
Proteus developed by a Scottish-based tech company, Xergy Group, is an end-to-end project management solution developed for the energy and engineering consulting industries.
Proteus is industry-proven and enables consultancies to meet project demands across the full lifecycle, from proposal development to project delivery. With robust sales and project delivery modules, Proteus helps its customers win more business, increase efficiencies, manage expenditures, and improve project controls.
Critical workflows, automation, and controls are integrated into Proteus. These include opportunity evaluation, proposal building, resource planning, budget tracking and forecasting, real-time multi-level restricted dashboards, and project performance analytics.
Third-party integrations and customised solutions allow Proteus’ users, which include C-suite, project leads, and engineers, to get the exact software solution needed for their business.
We offer a free onboarding consultation service to ensure your company account is set up to your company’s needs.
How to get Proteus
Proteus operates under a software-as-a-service (SaaS) model. We offer Enterprise packages and flexible pricing solutions: contact our team to learn more requests@xergy.com
We designed Proteus to be simple, and that means you can get up and running on Proteus without an IT team or support from a programmer. You will want to spend a bit of time configuring the admin console so that you have everything set up to suit your company structure, but it is intuitive and you don’t need a PhD in IT.
However, we want you to get the best out of what is a brilliantly powerful tool, so don’t hesitate to ask for our support. We have a team of product experts who are ready to help you with the configuration process, so get in touch today by filling out the form below:
